Monday, November 16, 2015

Research Blog #8: Interview/Primary Source Material

For my primary source, I have conducted an interview with an old friend and student-athlete at the University of Louisville. I asked questions to see which aspect student-athletes put their focus on more, athletics or academics, and how the university's attitudes towards its athletic program affect their direction of motivation.  Because of the recent scandal(s) at this specific university, I was asked to keep the student-athlete's identity anonymous.  

When asked if student-athletes tend to focus more on succeeding in academics or their sport, the student-athlete answered "I personally tend to focus more on my academics, but I would have to say that 90% of my team primarily focuses on sport."  

The student-athlete followed this up by saying "I think managing my time is one of the hardest things for me. Balancing the 20+ hours of athletics, along with commitments through the team surrounding the community and academics is a hard thing to do. I always try to put academics first but sometimes that just isn’t possible."


In regards to one of the greater revenue sports, football, this student-athlete noted that "when I got to school my freshman year" when football players were asked what their majors were "they replied 'football' and that they never planned on fully finishing their degree but rather getting drafted before that happened."








Research Blog #7: Your Case

My chief argument/case is that the attitudes of universities towards its intercollegiate athletics has direct effects on student-athletes and their ability to succeed academically.  Each university puts a larger focus on beefing up its athletic's department and spend a significantly larger amount of money in its athletics than its academics.  They are focused on creating a revenue stream in order to become a "first-rate university" through their athletics, at the complete expense of its academic standards and chief principle of educating its students and allowing them to reach their fullest academic potential.

Research Blog 6: Visual

The first graph shows the amount of spending per athlete(blue) compared to the amount of spending per student(red) at a university.  The data is from the KCIA and clearly shows that there is a significant difference in the amount of spending per student vs athlete.  Universities are spending around 6-7 times more on athletes compared to students over the span of 4 years from 2005-2008.  The numbers continue to increase as the years go on. 

This second graph shows the significant difference in salaries for 6 academic positions, including the University President/CEO, compared to Football coaches.  Football coaches are making around 3 times more than the University President/CEO's and even more than deans and teachers. This clearly shows that a university invests more into and values its athletics over its academics.  

Sunday, October 25, 2015

Literature Review Blog #3


Citation:

Kamusoko, Sibongile D., Ed.D, and Cynthia Lee A. Pemberton, Ed. D. "Student-Athlete 
Wellbeing and Persistence: An In-depth Look at Student-Athlete Perceptions." Student-Athlete Wellbeing 1 (2012): n. pag. ERIC [OCLC]. Web. 26 Oct. 2015. <http://files.eric.ed.gov/fulltext/ED528482.pdf>.


Summary:
The study conducted by Kamusoko focuses on student-athletes "perceptions of well-being, delimited to satisfaction regarding Athletic Department Policies and Practices, Educational Characteristics, Institutional Facilities and Services, and intent to academically persist."  The research conducted involved seven student-athletes, 5 male and 2 female.  Of the 7, 4 were team-sports while the other 3 were individual sports.  The study found four underlying themes that the student athletes 1) recognized their role, responsibilities, and agency in terms of their academic progress and relationships with faculty; 2) acknowledged reliance on the Athletic Department in terms of assistance in understanding and complying with NCAA rules, regulations, and eligibility requirements; 3) were aware of and made at least limited use of institution-based academic content support services, and 4) saw and valued themselves as students and student-athletes.

Author:
Sibongile D. Kamusoko and Cynthia Lee Pemberton, both were graduates of Idaho University.  Pemberton had publishes 2 books, and 31 papers.  Kamusoko is now a PE Adjunct Instructor at Idaho University and has published multiple papers as well.

Key Terms/Quotes
"Over time the NCAA developed from an exclusively men’s
sport organization concerned with establishing rules to minimize violent behavior, to a multi
division (D-I, D-II, and D-III) sport governance organization that has assumed fiscal
management, certification, and administrative control of most college sports (Maxcy, 2004).
Today, the NCAA describes itself as being “…[f]ounded more than one hundred years ago as a
way to protect student-athletes…[implementing] that principle with increased emphasis on both
athletics and academic excellence”"

"The problems student-athletes faced continued to escalate over the next two and a half
decades leading to the formation of a 1952 Presidential Committee by the American Council of
Education (ACE) (Thelin, 1994). This committee investigated and reported on ethics in
collegiate sport. More recently, the 1999 and the 2001 Knight Foundation Commission on
Intercollegiate Athletics (KFCIA) published reports that revealed and substantiated ongoing
conflicts between academic and athletic goals, such as admission practices for intercollegiate
athletes being at odds with institutional education goals"


" At each stage of reform the NCAA hoped that by better aligning the standards used to
admit student-athletes with those used by the institution for non-athletes, when student-athletes
arrived on a college campus they would be better able to meet athletic and academic demands.
This ideal was consistent with the 1991 KFCIA report that stated, “student-athletes will be
students as well as athletes” (p. 62). Despite NCAA legislative measures and requirements,
recent literature confirms that student-athletes still confront conflicting roles associated with
education and athletics (Hyatt, 2003; Nordeen, 2005; Suggs, 2003; Suggs, 2005; Wolverton,
2008). In addition, cases of academic fraud, in the form of altering athlete transcripts, acceptance
of lower admission standards, awarding grades for classes that athletes had not attended,
dishonesty, unethical practices, use of improper incentives from alumni, smear campaigns and
attacking programs at other institutions persist (Ferris, et al., 2004; Kelo, 2005; KFCIA, 1991,
2001, 2010; Maxcy, 2004; Thelin, 2004; Zimbalist, 1999)."


Value:
This source will be incredibly valuable for my research topic as it analyzes the structure of college sports and how the NCAA and other organizations have attempted to create strict guidelines on emphasizing the "student" aspect of a student-athlete.  There are some quality information and statistics presented in this paper that I can use to analyze a student-athlete's motivation and how it relates to their academic and athletic roles at a university.  By using the guidelines and regulations enforced by the institutions themselves, as well as the NCAA, it will be more simple to draw a picture of how the mind of a student-athlete works.

Literature Review Blog #2

Citation:
Mahoney, Michelle L. "Student-athletes' Perceptions of Their Academic and Athletic Roles: 
Intersections amongst Their Athletic Role, Academic Motivation, Choice of Major, and Career Decision Making."ProQuest. N.p., May 2011. Web. 8 Dec. 2015. <http://search.proquest.com.proxy.libraries.rutgers.edu/docview/903700328>.
Summary:
The Research conducted by Mahoney focuses on the intersections between a student-athlete's athletic and academic role.  She interviewed 18 student-athletes and found that some main themes emerged such as the athletic role being more reinforced than the academic role, and that student-athletes are part of an "elite group" in the eyes of the university.  She examines how the Role Theory and Role Conflict affect a student-athlete's view on their academic and athletic success.  What was interesting about Mahoney's study was that she found most of her subjects didn't view their responsibilities as academic or athletic, but as one interconnected responsibility.  It was almost as if they felt the burden to succeed academically and athletically as a way to "give back" to the university for giving them a scholarship.  This is where she examines how the stress levels for student-athletes sky rocket compared to non-athletes because of the pressure they face by being given a scholarship and being expected to succeed both academically and athletically.

Author:
Michelle L Mahoney.  She is a graduate from California State University-Long Beach where she received a Ed. D for Educational Leadership.  I am using her dissertation as a source.  She served at her alma mater as an Academic Counselor for Student-Athletes for 10 years from August 2003-January 2014.  She was an Athletic Academic Counselor at Mount San Antonio College for two years.  She has bounced around between colleges in California as an Adjunct Counselor.

Key Terms/Quotes:
Role Theory- a perspective in sociology and in social psychology that considers most of everyday activity to be the acting out of socially defined categories (e.g., mother, manager, teacher). Each social role is a set of rights, duties, expectations, norms and behaviours that a person has to face and fulfill.

Role Conflict-Role conflict occurs when there are incompatible demands placed upon an employee such that compliance with both would be difficult.

" Unlike other college students, student-athletes experience conflict between the competing time 
and energy demands of their academic role and their athletic role (Sack, 1987; Simons & 
Van Rheenen, 2000). "

"The numerous responsibilities, expectations, demands, and pressures produced by 

student-athletes' academic and athletic roles have implications for their college 
experiences. How student-athletes perceive their academic and athletic roles as well as 
strategies they employ to successfully navigate these multiple roles have only been 
explored in a limited manner. As such, an exploration of their perceptions is pertinent. 
Gaining knowledge about student-athletes' perceptions of, and ways in which they 
negotiate their multiple roles, could prove valuable for those working with the college 
student-athlete population, as well as beneficial to the creation and implementation of 
collegiate policy"



"Student-athletes fulfill a variety of roles, with the most prevalent being their 

academic and athletic roles. When fulfilling multiple roles, the potential to encounter 
role conflict exists. Such conflict can generally be thought of as the simultaneous 
manifestation of two or more incompatible expectations for the behavior of an individual 
(Biddle, 1986). "

Value:

This source will help explore my research problem by analyzing the sociology concept of Role theory and Role conflict and how it can be applied to student-athletes.  It focuses on the stresses student-athletes face in balancing their academic and athletic roles at a university and how they might handle such stresses.  It breaks down the roles of student-athletes to the very core by exploring the individual student-athlete and his/her motivation for academic success, how faculty interactions plays a factor, how the NCAA eligibility requirements influence choice of major, how student-athletes view their two roles as interconnected with push and pull components, how the student-athlete is viewed as a member of an "elite group" at the university, etc.

Literature Review Blog #1

Citation:

Gaston-Gayles, Joy L. "Examining Academic and Athletic Motivation Among Student Athletes at a Division I University." Journal of College Student Development 45.1 (2004): 75-83. Web.
Summary:
This sources examines academic motivation as a predictor of academic performance for college athletes.  The research study conducted in this source focuses on the "utility of academic and athletic motivation as a key variable in predicting academic performance among 211 college athletes at a Division I institution in the Midwest."  The study found that ACT/SAT scores, ethnicity, background characteristics, and pure academic motivation were significant factors in the "regression model."  The paper begins by examining graduation rates of student-athletes compared to non-athletes, as well as the percentages of the different demographics that make up the student-athletes (white basketball players, black basketball players, white football players, black football players, etc).  It goes on to examine certain predictors of academic success (such as the factors mentioned above) and how each one plays in to a student-athletes academic motivation.

Author:
Joy L. Gaston-Gayles is currently a professor at Florida State University with a focus in the Psychiatry and Psychology field of study.  She has published three research studies; two on student-athletes and their motivation toward academic success, and one on the experiences of a new faculty member in their first three years of employment in higher education administration institution.

Key Terms/Quotes:
"The most recent graduation rate report published by the National Collegiate Athletic Association (NCAA) indicates that athletes reached an all-time high graduation rate of 60%, compared to 58% for the non-athlete population (NCAA, 2002b). Despite the academic support services that are strongly encouraged and available for student athletes, not all groups of athletes are graduating at the national rate. For example, White basketball players graduated at a rate of 53%, but Black basketball players graduated at a rate of 35%. White football players' graduation rate was 62% and Black football players experienced a 45% graduation rate." Page 1

"The most common predictors of academic performance have traditionally been high school GPA and rank, standardized test scores, and parental education" Page 1

"The seven non-cognitive variables assessed through the Non-Cognitive Questionnaire (NCQ) and reported to be related to academic success are: (a) positive self-concept, (b) realistic self-appraisal, (c) understanding and dealing with racism, (d) setting long-term goals, (e) strong support system, (f) leadership experiences, and (g) community service experience. Further, when SAT scores were combined with non-cognitive variables, predictions of success were more accurate. Non-cognitive variables accurately predict academic performance across 4 years, whereas standardized test scores are only predictive of the first year of college performance." Page 1


This material will help me explore my research question by providing hard facts and statistics on predicting academic success for student-athletes.  It takes a unique approach by analyzing a student-athletes background and demographic in predicting their academic success over the course of four years of undergraduate studying.  This differs from some of my other sources that focus on the present circumstances of a student-athlete at a university and how their current situation plays a role in their academic/athletic success.  It allows for a different perspective of analysis, which is only more beneficial to my research paper.

Reseach Blog #5: Bibliography with Five Schoalrly Sources

Working Bibliography
Gaston-Gayles, Joy L. "Examining Academic and Athletic Motivation Among Student Athletes
at a Division 1 University." Journal of College Student Development 45.1 (2004): 75-83. Web. 27 Oct. 2015. <http://muse.jhu.edu/journals/journal_of_college_student_development/v045/45.1gaston-gayles.pdf>.
Hochfield, George. "The Incompatibility of Athletic and Academic Excellence." N.p., n.d. Web.
Kamusoko, Sibongile D., Ed.D, and Cynthia Lee A. Pemberton, Ed. D. "Student-Athlete
Wellbeing and Persistence: An In-depth Look at Student-Athlete Perceptions." Student-Athlete Wellbeing 1 (2012): n. pag. ERIC [OCLC]. Web. 26 Oct. 2015. <http://files.eric.ed.gov/fulltext/ED528482.pdf>.
Mahoney, Michelle L. "Student-Athletes' Perceptions of their Academic and Athletic Roles:
Intersections Amongst their Athletic Role, Academic Motivation, Choice of Major, and Career Decision Making." Order No. 3483946 California State University, Long Beach, 2011. Ann Arbor: ProQuest. <http://search.proquest.com/docview/903700328> Web. 26 Oct. 2015.
Shulman, James Lawrence, and William G. Bowen. The Game of Life: College Sports and
Educational Values. Princeton, N.J. ; Oxford: Princeton University Press, 2001.
Simons, Herbert D., Derek Van Rheenen, and Martin V. Covington. "Academic Motivation."
SpringerReference (2011): n. pag. Web. 20 Oct. 2015.
<http://leep.berkeley.edu/sites/default/files/users/derek-van-rheenen/Covington,%20Simons%20%26%20Van%20Rheenen,%20Academic%20motivation%20and%20the%20student%20athlete.pdf>.